Wow, this summer was a whirlwind! Last March, Chris and I sat down and made a list of 10 projects we wanted to complete this summer. With things like “replace the shingles” and “fix the siding”, it became clear that the exterior was going to be our focus for the summer! And what a transformation it has been!
Shall we do a few dramatic before and afters??
Here’s how our house looked when we moved in –
Before
And here’s how it looks today!
After
Before
After
What a difference isn’t it?! New siding, cleaned up landscaping, new paint, a few new windows, and a lot of hard work!! (Imagine how beautiful it will be when the trees have leaves again!!?)
Let’s start with the siding. We originally planned on keeping the red metal siding and just replacing a few rows that were rusty, power washing the rest, and repainting it. But then we had a hail storm that damaged a good portion of our siding and we quickly realized that between the hail damage and the rust, this siding wasn’t worth saving.
So we decided to reside our house entirely and start from scratch. We landed on board and batten with a wood grain texture which felt like the perfect siding style for the “cabin tucked in the trees” vibe we were going for. But before we could do that, we had to rip off all the old siding first. There were two layers of siding actually…red metal siding on top and cedar wood lap siding underneath. Neither were in great shape so we pulled off everything until we reached the sheathing underneath. Seeing this house as a blank slate was actually super refreshing. We could finally see our vision coming to life!
We hired my brother who’s a general contractor in Minnesota to help us start installing the board and batten. Neither Chris or I had ever done this before and having someone with experience and a perfectionist mindset like me was the right move. We learned so much from him and he helped us install nearly half the house! We tackled the rest of the house on our own and surprisingly we finished it without any hiccups or emergency phones calls to my brother! Our siding is from LP SmartSide and we love it! I shared all the details about our siding in this post if you’d like to read more about it.
Painting our siding was an experience in of itself. In summary, we painted our house 3 times in 3 different colors because I couldn’t find the perfect color. It was an emotional rollercoaster that you’re welcome to read more about here if you dare! 😉 But apparently the third time’s the charm because we finally landed on this perfect muddy green color and we couldn’t love it more! It’s deep and moody and it compliments the grass, trees, and soon to come landscaping wonderfully. It’s called “Subterranean” from HGTV Home by Sherwin Williams! More details on how we painted our siding here.
NOTE: The color name has since changed and is now called “Muddled Basil” by Sherwin Williams.
Our passthrough got a transformation of its own with a new window and cedar shakes. I wanted to incorporate at least 2 siding materials to break up the monotony of board and batten and it quickly became our favorite part of the house. For now the cedar shakes are natural but I’m hoping they’ll age into a beautiful weathered gray patina. For a closer look at our passthrough and cedar shakes, read this post.
Simple things like pairing smooth fascia trim along the roof line with the textured siding is what reminds me that the little details matter. Or the trim around each window with a sill and a border that transform our standard windows into a moment. It’s those details that make an otherwise overlooked element turn into a beautifully intentional feature.
Before
You may have noticed that the shingles are different too. Our roof was also damaged from the hail storm and we were very fortunate to replace the shingles at the same time as our siding. More on that here.
I titled this blog post “Phase 1 Reveal” because there’s still a lot to do…most of which won’t happen till next summer. Landscaping is at the top of our list and we cannot wait to rip out the existing layout and start fresh with with all new plants. A railing for our front porch, new stairs, new pathway, an extensive amount of work in the back yard including a deck, and potentially refinishing our front door are also on the list and I think we’ll need all winter to figure out what we want.
You can see a peek in the photo below that we left a portion of our siding with the original horizontal lap siding and simply painted it a warm white for the time being. That whole portion will get a new roof and cedar shakes next summer if all goes as planned!
Sometimes I think back and remember that we originally planned on simply repainting our old siding. Can you imagine how different our house would have looked?! I’m sure it would’ve been beautiful but now that we’ve truly uncovered the potential of this home’s exterior, I can’t imagine it any other way. There’s more to come, but for now we’re thoroughly enjoying what we have accomplished!
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Where behind the scenes, exclusive advice, and candid conversations are sent straight to your inbox every week.
I am in LOVE with the color of your front door. What stain color/brand did you choose??
Thank you so much! The stain color is Puritan Pine by Minwax!
I love the color of your house! We have looked through many pictures and have decided to give it a try.
I am curious, did you paint the gutters and downspouts or were you able to find a green gutter that matched?
We painted the gutters and downspouts as well! We used this specialty primer so the paint would adhere well. It’s been 4 years and the paint has held up incredibly well!
Where is your front door from?
We purchased it from Lowes, but unfortunately it’s no longer available there.
Hi! Where did you find your exterior lights?
Hi Andi! We purchased this light – https://rstyle.me/+2DRzbJNSmb2VcQNNbSq2ng
And painted it antique brass with this spray paint – https://rstyle.me/+GizrCL6zK8aeumFj1BbulA
Random Q, where’s your front door handle from!? Love it
Hi Courtney! Here’s a link to it – https://rstyle.me/n/dxrbsccqxjp
Are the photos filtered? I purchased a sample can and tested it on my garage and it looks more gray/brown. Also, in case anyone is curious, this color has been renamed by Sherwin-Williams to Muddled Basil.
Thanks for the heads up on the name change! The colors in the photos are true to life. But with any paint color, it can look vastly different from one home to another due to differences in lighting and surroundings.
This is INCREDIBLE. Absolutely STUNNING!
Thank you so much Shelbe! 🙂
I love this color you finally chose for the exterior. Did you paint the trim the same color? It looks like it is but not sure.
Thank you! Yes, the siding, trim, and fascia are all the same color.
fantastic siding choice and color!! kudos to pushing past your comfort zone and finding something that felt right. i’m new here but I couldnt help but notice some letters nicely painted on the (original?) cedar lap siding! how amazing! have you addressed the history of the property and the text/painting before? I’m guessing it said LUMBER? I’m a weirdo so I can’t help but think how cool it would look to have left that exposed, or to recreate those letters on your new siding. I also love seeing where the original cutouts were for windows in previous centuries. its interesting to me how great the scale and proportions were (windows/doorways to rooflines, building mass) and how they’ve been adjusted and reframed in years since. i’m curious (again, i know) if any of those openings could have been resuscitated in an effort to bring a visual, proportional harmony back to certain areas, even as a folly/false opening? again, great work, very inspiring!
Thanks Dave! Yes, we can’t find much information on our house but the little we have found shows that our home was once a lumber store. Took lots of photos for history sake, but we weren’t able to keep it exposed since it was painted directly onto the sheathing. Fun to discover the history though!
I can see how much work and love went into this huge project. You should be so proud of your work as the results are just beautiful. Well done!
Thank you so much Kassie!! We feel so blessed to call this place home! 🙂
Oh shoot I might just steal this whole vibe for my house!
🙂 You’d get no judgement from me!
LOVE IT! You guys should be so proud!Such a great color and love the shakes in the ‘new’ area!
Thank you so much Stacey!! 🙂 It’s been such a fun summer project!